Logo for the Poetess Archive

TEI-encoded version

Elizabeth InchbaldREMARKS [on The Rival Queens]. 1
______

Nathaniel Lee, the author of this tragedy, was the son of Dr. Lee, minister of Hatfield. He received his early education under Busby, at Westminster School, and was afterwards a student at Trinity College, Cambridge.2

Disappointed in some hopes which he had formed upon the munificence of King Charles the Second, he turned his thoughts towards the stage for his support, and ventured his abilities as a performer.3 Discouraged in this attempt, yet enthralled by the charms of a theatre, he encountered the perils of a dramatist, and was successful.

Cibber has mentioned, with wonder, the talents which Lee discovered in reading, as he was wholly destitute of eloquence in public speaking. He was so excellent a reader of his own plays at the rehearsals, Cibber says,—that the very first actors have thrown down their parts, in despair of giving equal force or pathos in performing them; yet, as an actor, he had neither the one requisite nor the other.4 To persons well acquainted with theatrical qualifications, there is nothing wonderful in this intelligence. b 2[Page 4]The relater of it himself must have known, from long experience, that many a fine reader cannot act; and that many a fine actor cannot read. This observation, of course, applies to a superlative degree of excellence in either art.

Amongst all the plays, which this author produced, "The Rival Queens, or Alexander the Great," has been, and still remains, the most popular: there is popularity even in its high sounding title; nor do these outside words give an unsuitable specimen of of [sic] those which are contained within.

This tragedy is calculated for representation, rather than the amusement of the closet;—for, though it is graced with some beautiful poetry, it is likewise deformed by an extravagance, both in thought and in language, that at times verges upon the ludicrous. Actors, eminent in their art, know how to temper those failings in a tragic author: they give rapidity to their utterance in the mock sublime, and lengthen their cadence upon every poetic beauty.

Lee and Dryden sometimes united their labours in the production of a drama. This play, and "All for Love,"5 were written by each separately, and yet there is a near resemblance of the one to the other.—The characters and events are historical in both; and Clytus6 in this, and Ventidius in that, play, form such an equal contrast to the tragic scenes, that it appears the two poets thought alike, though they wrote asunder.

Dryden's Octavia is, however, much less refined than Lee's Statira.7 The first pardons her husband's [Page 5]love to Cleopatra, and is willing to accept his reluctant return, with an alienated heart;—whilst the last makes a solemn vow, never more to behold the man who loves her to distraction, because he has given her one proof of incontinence. There is deep knowledge of the female heart evinced in both these incidents. A woman is glad to be reconciled to the husband, who does not love her, upon any conditions—whilst the wife, who is beloved, is outrageous if she be not adored. Yet Lee should have considered, that such delicate expectation of perpetual constancy, as he has given to his pagan queen, Statira, were not, so late as his own time, prevalent, even among christian queens. The consorts of Charles the Second and Louis the Fourteenth, saw as many partakers of their royal spouses' love, as the Sultana of Constantinople,8 —and with equal patience.

Barry was the last actor who acquired fame in the part of Alexander—he had every qualification, both in person and voice, for a hero and a lover. The play never failed of attraction in his youthful days; and its importance on the stage would be renewed by any performer of his peculiar abilities.

Yet all Barry's endowments for this character appear to have fallen infinitely beneath those of Hart, the original hero.

This Hart, it is reported by his biographers, made love, in Alexander, "with such godlike ardour, that spectators could scarcely once doubt of his immediate descent from Jupiter."9 Nor was this performer's warmth of passion confined to his fictitious charac-b 3[Page 6]ters; he possessed it as a quality of his own, and was the man who beguiled poor Nell Gwyn from selling oranges at the playhouse door, and instructed her to become an actress. But soon she forsook the counterfeit King of Macedon, for the real King of England,—and became mother of the Duke of St. Albans.

The dreadful calamity which befel Lee, soon after the writing of this tragedy, is well known; yet no particular cause has been assigned for the affliction with which he was visited! Having progressively fallen into a state of insanity, he was confined in Bedlam for four years.10 In his lucid intervals, he had industry, and followed his wonted occupation of writing plays; and his description of a madman, in one of those productions, is surely, considering his own situation at the time, the most curious and interesting passage he ever wrote.

 

Description of a Madman, by Lee.

To my charm'd ears no more of woman tell:Name not a woman, and I shall be well.Like a poor lunatic, that makes his moan,And for a while beguiles his lookers on,He reasons well—his eyes their wildness lose,He vows the keepers his wrong'd sense abuse.But if you hint the cause that hurt his brain,Then his teeth gnash, he foams, he shakes his chain,His eyeballs roll, and he is mad again.11 space between stanzas

[Page 7]

Lee was, happily, restored to society from his miserable confinement, though he did not long enjoy his liberty.

He died suddenly in the streets, at the age of thirty-four.12

The severe indisposition, to which he was subject, may possibly have had influence in guiding his pen to some of those flights of imagination, called by the sober critic—phrenzy. But thus the great Dryden speaks of those flights, and of those critics who censure them.

 

Despise those drones, who praise, while they accuse,The too much vigour of your youthful museThat humble style, which they their virtue make,Is in your power—you need but stoop and takeYour beauteous images must be allow'dBy all, but some vile poets of the crowd:But how should any sign-post dauber knowThe worth of Titian, or of Angelo?13 space between stanzas

Notes

1.  "Remarks." The Rival Queens; or, the Death of Alexander the Great; A Tragedy, In Five Acts; By Nathaniel Lee. As Performed at the Theatres Royal, Drury Lane and Covent Garden. Printed Under the Authority of the Managers From the Prompt Book. With Remarks by Mrs. Inchbald. Printed for Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme, Paternoster Row, pp. 3-7. The British Theatre; or, A Collection of Plays, Which Are Acted At the Theatres Royal, Drury Lane, Covent Garden, and Haymarket. Printed Under the Authority of the Managers from the Prompt Books. With Biographical and Critical Remarks, by Mrs. Inchbald. In Twenty-Five Volumes. Vol. VI. Rule a Wife and Have a Wife. Chances. New Way to Pay Old Debts. Alexander the Great. All for Love. London: Printed for Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme, Paternoster Row. 1808. The first performance of this play was staged at the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane on March 17th, 1677. Laura DeWitt and Mary A. Waters edited this essay for The Criticism Archive. Back

2.  Lee received his Bachelor of Arts degree from Trinity College in 1668. Back

3.  Upon his arrival in London, Lee tried to earn his living as an actor, but acute stage fright prevented him from furthering this career. Back

4.  This story is recounted in Daniel Bellamy's The Young Ladies Miscellany (1723), pp. vi, ix. Back

5.  John Dryden's 1677 play, All for Love follows the story of Mark Antony and Cleopatra. Back

6.  Master of the Horse and Alexander the Great's trusted and faithful adviser. Back

7.  Originally a captive, she became the devoted wife of Alexander the Great and Queen of Babylon. Back

8.  The sultans of the Ottoman Empire often had multiple wives as part of the imperial harem. This frequently led to jealousy among the wives, particularly revolving around the Haseki, the title for the Sultan's favorite. Back

9.  Quote unidentified at present. Hart's acting in the part of Alexander has been commended in John Downes' Roscius Anglicanus (1708), Thomas Davies' Dramatic Miscellanies (1784, vol. 3), and multiple diary entries of Samuel Pepys, yet these works do not contain similar phrasing to the above quote. Charles Maturin's Melmoth the Wanderer notes Hart's "godlike ardour in making love" in the part of Alexander. However, this work was not published until 1820. Back

10.  Lee was committed to the psychiatric Bedlam Hospital in 1684. Back

11.  From Lee's Caesar Borgia (1679), Act V, scene i. Back

12.  Lee died in obscurity after a bout of drinking at the age of 39. Back

13.  From Dryden's "To Mr. Lee, on his Alexander" (1677). Back