Logo for the Poetess Archive

TEI-encoded version

Elizabeth InchbaldREMARKS [on Every Man in His Humour]. 1
______

Ben Jonson, the author of this play, was born in London, in the year 1574, just a month after the death of his father.

The father had been a clergyman, and the son received his education at Westminster School:2 but the mother having married a second time, and having condescended to bestow her hand upon a bricklayer, poor Benjamin, on quitting school, was compelled by his father-in-law to work at that business.3

He escaped from this dull and laborious employment, by enlisting for a soldier; and being sent to the Netherlands, distinguished himself by remarkable courage in his military capacity.4

Literature was, however, the pursuit of his inclination: for, on his return to England, he entered himself at St. John's College, Cambridge; from whence he removed, after some years of strict application, for want of the means to support himself longer as a student.5

He now applied to that profession for a maintenance, which poverty, united to literary taste, directs thousands to pursue—the stage. The learned Ben Jonson became a strolling player, in an obscure b 2[Page 4]company of comedians, who performed occasionally at the sign of the Curtain in Shoreditch.6 Soon after, he had the good fortune to be a member of the same theatrical community with Shakspeare, and received Shakspeare's advice and assistance in commencing dramatic writer.7

Tradition says—and Davies, in his Miscellanies, confirms its probability—that Ben Jonson, having written this comedy of "Every Man in his Humour," presented it to one of the managers of that theatre, where Shakspeare was engaged as an actor. The manager, after casting his eye carelessly over the work, was on the point of returning it with a peremptory refusal, when Shakspeare, who chanced to be present, requested leave to read the play: he was so well pleased on the perusal, that he recommended it with such force, as induced the manager to change the opinion he had formed in its disfavour, and to bring it on the stage.8

Its success was very great. Shakspeare not only patronized, but performed in this comedy; but here his talents were subordinate, and he was, of course, less useful than as a commentator before its representation. It is supposed he acted the part of Kno'well,9 by his name being first in the Dramatis Personæ of the original copy. Shakspeare was at that time in his thirty-fourth, and Jonson in his twenty-fourth year.

Notwithstanding the merit of this play, it was wholly neglected as a stage exhibition, from the time of its revival, at the Restoration, till Garrick, in [Page 5]1749, brought it once more before the public, with some few alterations.10

Garrick's Kitely, and Woodward's Bobadil,11 are described by the frequenters of the theatre of that period, as performances of the most exquisite art.

From Garrick's death till Cooke appeared, the play was again neglected; for without peculiar excellence in the representation of Kitely, it has but little attraction. Cooke has the praise of having given it all its former power over the town, and to have fully supplied the vacant post of Garrick.12

Including tragedies, comedies, operas, masques, et cetera, printed and unprinted, Ben Jonson produced no less than fifty-three dramas; not one of which, excepting the present comedy, holds its place among acting plays.13

High as this author ranks as a classic, it is a subject of wonder that the wits and men of taste, those idolators of the drama in Charles the Second's reign, should prefer him before Shakspeare! This mystery is resolved by some persons, on the supposition of the ascendancy of the Duke of Buckingham's sentiments upon questions of this nature, over those of the other courtiers; and his Grace, from early years, had been an enthusiastic admirer of Jonson. At the age of thirteen he was personally acquainted with him; at which time Ben was in his grand climacteric.14

In comparing this author with his contemporary Shakspeare, as men, the last has a superiority over the former in the benevolence, as well as the capa-b 3[Page 6]ciousness, of his mind. He was generous and kind to Jonson, whilst Jonson, incited, it is supposed, by envy, did not forbear to ridicule the works of his friend and benefactor.15 Here, at least, Jonson showed the talent of sound judgment, and the virtue of humility; for had he conceived his own productions the best, all discontent at his neighbour's perfection had been annihilated:—and while Shakspeare bore without retort his depreciating insinuations, it is possible, he was withheld by the pride of preeminence, more than by the moral force of patience. As players, there seems to have been no contention between these friends, for superiority—they were both too unskilful in this, their other, art to inspire either with emulation.

On the accession of James the First to the throne, Jonson was appointed to the management of all the masques and public spectacles; and he continued in this office during that and the succeeding reign.

In 1615, he was made poet laureate; and had so much interest at court as to procure a rise in the salary from a hundred marks (13s. 4d.)to a hundred pounds a year, with the comfortable addition of a butt of Canary wine.16

Notwithstanding this pension, and the profits arising from his various productions, he had not the economy to live independent. He was often so reduced in his finances, as to be compelled to inhabit lodgings in a wretched alley, where the bounty of his sovereign, as well as that of his fellow subjects, has often followed him to administer relief.17

[Page 7]

In this wretched termination of his life, he sunk once more beneath his great rival Shakspeare; for Shakspeare retired, long previous to his death, to the comforts of leisure and independence; nor ever made drafts on the compassion of mankind for the pleasures of existence.18

Ben Jonson died in 1637, was buried in Westminster Abbey; and his gravestone has merely the following words, to denote the extraordinary gifts, of which he had been possessed. O Rare Ben Jonson!19 space between stanzas

Notes

1.  "Remarks." Every Man in His Humour; A Comedy, In Five Acts; By Ben Jonson. As Performed at the Theatres Royal, Drury Lane and Covent Garden. Printed Under the Authority of the Managers From the Prompt Book. With Remarks by Mrs. Inchbald. Printed for Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme, Paternoster Row, pp. 3-7. The British Theatre; or, A Collection of Plays, Which Are Acted At the Theatres Royal, Drury Lane, Covent Garden, and Haymarket. Printed Under the Authority of the Managers from the Prompt Books. With Biographical and Critical Remarks, by Mrs. Inchbald. In Twenty-Five Volumes. Vol. V. Coriolanus. Othello. Tempest. Twelfth Night. Every Man in His Humour. London: Printed for Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme, Paternoster Row. 1808. The first performance of this play was staged at the Curtain Theatre in September of 1598. Laura DeWitt and Mary A. Waters edited this essay for The Criticism Archive. Back

2.  A prestigious London school associated with the Benedictines that enjoyed royal patronage during the 16th century, when Jonson would have attended. Back

3.  Upon his graduation from Westminster in 1589, Jonson matriculated at St. John's College at Cambridge to continue his education. For want of funds, he was made to return to his family a month later to complete an apprenticeship with his stepfather. Back

4.  According to the Notes of Ben Jonson's Conversations with William Drummond of Hawthornden (published by the Shakespeare Society in 1842 from Drummond's long-lost notes of his conversations with Jonson, Jonson engaged in single combat in Flanders, Belgium, and emerged victorious, having stripped his opponent of his weapons in full view of both armies (p. 18). Single combat is an antique style of duel in which the two combatants fight in the no-man's-land between the armies, typically with the other soldiers watching and waiting to fight themselves until the duel is complete. Back

5.  Here Inchbald's chronology is inaccurate. Jonson had attended St. John's College for a period of only a few weeks prior to his bricklaying apprenticeship and subsequent military service. Back

6.  By 1597, Jonson had a fixed engagement with the acting troupe The Admiral's Men. In 1598, his play Every Man in his Humour was performed at The Curtain Theatre in the Shoreditch neighborhood of London. Back

7.  While there are many legends surrounding the supposed friendship and/or rivalry between the two men, the extent to which Shakespeare and Jonson interacted is debated. It is certain that the two knew each other personally, as Shakespeare's acting company, the Lord Chamberlain's Men (renamed the King's Men in 1603), produced many of Jonson's plays. Shakespeare is known to have acted in at least two of Jonson's plays, Every Man in his Humour and Sejanus His Fall. Although Jonson was known to have been critical of Shakespeare's style (Jonson recording himself as having replied "Would he had blotted a thousand!" upon being told by fellow actors that Shakespeare never crossed out a line he had written), his recorded criticisms of Shakespeare are outnumbered by his considerable public tributes. In his posthumously-published Timber, or Discoveries made upon men and matter, as they have flowed out of his daily readings, or had their reflux to his peculiar notion of the times (1641), Jonson clarifies that he had intended no malevolence in his criticism of Shakespeare, writing that "There was ever more in him to be praysed, than to be pardoned." (p. 98). Back

8.  This theatre legend is recounted in Thomas Davies' Dramatic Miscellanies (1783), vol. 2, pp. 55-56. It was first recorded by Nicholas Rowe in the preface, "Some Account of the Life &c. of Mr. William Shakespear," of his larger The works of Mr. William Shakespear (1709, vol. 1, p. XII-XIII). This tradition was handed down by word of mouth in the theatrical community, though it is unsupported by any other evidence. Back

9.  It is believed that Shakespeare played the part of Old Knowell, the father of Edward Knowell and master of the servant Brainworm. Old Knowell is an overbearing parent, worrying over Edward's interest in poetry and trying to sabotage his literary career. Back

10.  David Garrick's adaptation of the play focused on the jealousy of Thomas Kitely, a merchant, as he unfairly suspects his wife of adultery. Back

11.  Captain Bobadil, the boastful soldier who is ultimately revealed to lack bravery. Back

12.  George Cooke revived the play at Covent Garden in 1800, for a total of ten performances between 1800 and 1801. In 1803, Cooke alternated the role of Kitely with John Philip Kemble. Cooke's final 1808 attempt to revive the play in Edinburgh failed. Back

13.  Jonson is estimated to have written, or co-written, at least 20 plays, 36 masques (a form of festive court entertainment), and 11 miscellaneous works. Every Man in his Humour was the last of Jonson's plays being performed at the time this essay was written. Back

14.  George Villiers, Duke of Buckingham, King James I, and King Charles I were all appreciators of Jonson's masques. Back

15.  See footnote 6. Back

16.  With the first payment of his pension in 1616, Jonson became the first unofficial poet laureate, a position which was not established as an official royal office until 1668 with the selection of John Dryden. When he first received his pension, Jonson was granted 100 marks (a mark being worth 13 shillings and 4 pence) a year. In 1630, the amount was increased from 100 marks to 100 pounds (a pound being worth 20 shillings). At this time Jonson also began receiving 42 gallons of Canary wine per year from the king's store at Whitehall as a supplement to his pension. Back

17.  After a period of declining productivity in the 1620s and suffering what was most likely a stroke in 1628, the end of Jonson's life was characterized by financial hardship. This is supported by the fact that he was buried upright, a practice for those who could not afford to occupy more square footage in a cemetery. It has been said that Jonson appealed to Charles I for this meagre plot. Back

18.  Nicholas Rowe first recorded the tradition of Shakespeare's retirement in Stratford in the preface, "Some Account of the Life &c. of Mr. William Shakespear," of his larger The works of Mr. William Shakespear (1709, vol. 1, p. XXXV). Back

19.  The inscription on Ben Jonson's tombstone in Westminster Abbey. According to John Aubrey, the inscription was commissioned on impulse by Jack Young, who happened to be passing by as the grave was being covered ('Brief Lives,' chiefly of Contemporaries, set down by John Aubrey, between the years 1669 & 1696, edited by Andrew Clark, 1898, p. 13). Back